Operation-Ruin-Lebanses-Infrastructure...Is it proportional?
don't kid youselfWill it solve our Hezbollah problems?
not on it's ownIs it necessary?
yes.Valentine's 3-Step Guide to Peace in the Middle East Step (1) Undermine Lebanese support of Hezbollah.
Step (2) Get the world to comdemn/attack Syria and Iran.
Step (3) Deal with Hamas.
While Hezbollah is responsible for the kidnappings and northern attacks on Israel, Lebanon has been housing the organization, and Syria and Iran have been financing its efforts. The only way to properly combat Hezbollah is to shut it down on all sides: first undermine Lebanese support, then go on to attack its supporters/financers: Syria and Iran.
(1) Undermine Lebanese SupportSome history: (special thanks to Wikipedia)Hezbollah, along with the mainly leftist and secular groups in the Lebanese National Resistance Front, fought a guerilla war against Israel and the Israeli proxy South Lebanon Army, causing Israel to withdraw its army from south Lebanon in May of 2000.
Hezbollah's role in the Israeli withdrawal from southern Lebanon gained the organization much respect in Lebanon and the wider Arab and Islamic world, particularly among the country's large Shi'a community. The President of Lebanon, Emile Lahoud, said: "For us Lebanese, and I can tell you the majority of Lebanese, Hezbollah is a national resistance movement. If it wasn't for them, we couldn't have liberated our land. And because of that, we have big esteem for the Hezbollah movement."
At that time, Israel withdrew from Lebanon to the UN-agreed Israeli border, and their pullout was certified by the UN as complete. However, Hezbollah still claims the Shebaa Farms, a 28 sq. km. area, which is still occupied by Israel, to be Lebanese territory, and on that basis has continued to engage Israeli forces in that area.
Since then, Hezbollah abducted three IDF soldiers during an October 2000 attack in Shebaa Farms, and sought to obtain the release of 14 Lebanese prisoners, some of whom had been held since 1978. On January 25, 2004, Hezbollah successfully negotiated through German mediators Israel agreed on an exchange of prisoners. 30 Lebanese and Arab prisoners, the remains of 60 Lebanese militants and civilians, 420 Palestinian prisoners, and maps showing Israeli mines in South Lebanon were exchanged for an Israeli businessman and army reserve colonel kidnapped in 2001 and the remains of the three IDF soldiers mentioned above, who were killed either during the Hezbollah operation, or in its immediate aftermath.
And Today (well, yesterday):Hezbollah kidnaps two Israeli soldiers, demanding a prisoner trade for the remaining three Lebanese prisoners held by Israel.
My2Cents:It worked in the past...that was a mistake. Will it work this time? No.
Nasrallah promised he would kidnap Israelis to get his people back, but what will happen when Israel promises to ruin Lebanese infrastructure until it gets its soldiers back? Welcome to Operation-Ruin-Lebanese-Infrastructure. Is it a proportional response? probably not, but it's the only way to show Lebanon that (a) we hold the cards, not Nasrallah and (b) that Nasrallah's interests are not inline with the Lebanese cause, destroying Lebanese infrastructure will hopefully distroy support for Nasrallah in Lebanon, and make him go to Syria/Iran where (a) he gets along with them much better but (b) the world doesnt so much at all.
Step (2) Get the world to comdemn/attack Syria and Iran.They have nuclear weapons, they support terrorist organizations, the world condemned them after the Hezbollah kidnappings, how hard would it be to get the world to do something against them? HARD
For some reason Israel can't get people to stay behind it (unless people is the United States or Britain)...
So, I'm still working on Step 2...I'll get back to you with that one, in the mean time I'll email Bush and ask him if I could borrow some ICBMs...
Step (3) Deal with Hamas.When (and by when I really, unfortunately mean if) Hamas no longer has Syria/Iran to back its efforts, and no longer has Hezbollah cheering it on from the north, what will happen to the organization that no one - neither Israel nor any of the Arab states, - wanted in its country?
In the mean time, we will have to continue our defenses in the west, protect against further kidnappings and kassam rockets, and respond with proportional(?) military aggression in gaza.
If only it were that easy.
But throught this all, our prayers go out to the civlians whose lives were taken away from them, the soldiers, their families, and of course, the state of Israel.